Contact us


Bo: Pharaoh's Illogical Behaviour

Published on Thursday February 18th, 2021

One of the most distinctive aspects of the Ten Plagues was the persistent refusal of Pharaoh to recognize the error of his ways and accept that the G-d of the Jews was indeed all-powerful.  Miracle after miracle failed to persuade him of the veracity of Moshe Rabbeinu''s claims of being Hashem's shliach(messenger) and not merely an expert sorcerer.  During the first five plagues he refused to release the Jews whilst in full control of his free will.   In the second five plagues he would have sent the Jews out of Mitzrayim had Hashem not hardened his heart.  The Seforno explains, however, that this does not mean that the plagues caused Pharaoh to do teshuva from a recognition of the greatness of Hashem, rather his inability to bear any more plagues would have been the cause of permitting the Jews to leave.  Accordingly, Hashem's hardening of his heart gave him to strength to overcome his natural fear and make a 'reasoned' free will decision to continue to refuse Moshe's requests[1].   

Pharaoh's seemingly superhuman stubbornness aroused great wonderment in Rav Aaron Bakst, zt"l, Rosh Yeshiva of Lomza.  He used to give a mussar shmueze in his home every leil Shabbos.  On one occasion his talmidim entered his house and were surprised to see him walking back and forth in his room, speaking to himself, "what was Pharaoh thinking when he saw these great miracles in front of his very eyes?!" Suddenly, he stopped walking, turned to the talmidim and explained, "he did not think at all! Only through lack of thinking can a person come to ignore such great miracles without allowing them to influence him in the slightest[2]!"

This explanation of Pharaoh's illogical behavior sheds great light on why people fail to change when they experience great events.  They may even recognize that miracles have occurred but they do not think about their consequences. An example of this was people's reaction to the open miracles of the Gulf War in which 39 scud missiles succeeded in killing just one person[3].  One leading secular Israeli politician acknowledged that the nation had clearly witnessed then hand of G-d.  Yet, Rav Dovid Orlofsky Shlita points out, Rabin did not change his lifestyle one iota, he did not start wearing tefillin, or keeping Mitzvos.  One may ask, what was he thinking?! He has clearly seen G-d's hand in protecting the Jewish people and yet he didn't change! The answer is found in Rav Bakst's explanation - he did not think!  Had he sincerely reflected on the remarkable events he would have surely changed in some way.

Another striking illustration of this phenomenon is told over by Rav Dovid Kaplan Shlita.  Rav Chatzkel Levenstein zt"l was traveling in a taxi with a chillonidriver.  The driver turned to Rav Chatzkel and told him the following remarkable story: Several years earlier, he had been traveling in the jungles of Africa with some friends.  Suddenly, a snake attacked one of them, wrapping it's large body around him, causing him to suffocate. After concerted efforts to save him, they realized that there was no hope, so they told him to say the Shema before he left the world.  He quickly said it and immediately the snake uncurled itself and left. This man, his life saved, was profoundly effected by this event, and gradually returned to Judaism and he was now a fully observant Jew. After hearing how this even so drastically changed the friend's life, Rav Chatzkel turned to the driver and asked him why he had not changed as a result of this miracle.  The driver explained, "oh no, it didn't happen to me, it happened to him[4]."  

The driver saw a potentially life-changing event but did not change; why? because he did not think, he did not let the obvious consequences of this miracle cause him to reflect on his life direction.  It is also instructive to note that his friend, the subject of the miracle, did change - sometimes an event can be so powerful that a person cannot help but think about it and allow it to influence his life.  However, often, we ourselves are not the subject of the miracle and therefore it requires far more conscious effort to force ourselves to 'think' about the ramifications of events that we see and hear about.

The recent events in the war in Gaza also constitute open displays of Hashem's hands.  Rabbanim have told numerous stories of miracles that occurred there. Moreover, many have noted that the numerous missiles fired into Israel have had a miraculously minimal effect. Our avoda is to let such events cause us to think about our lives - to reassess our awareness of G-d in the world and in our lives; to think about what G-d is communicating to us; and to see how we can change and grow. The first stage of changing as a result of the world around us is to learn the lesson of Pharaoh and to 'think' - to let events that happen in the world at large, and that occur in our own private lives, cause us to reflect on our lives, and make necessary changes.  May we all merit to 'think' about that which happens around us.




[1]Seforno, Va'eira, 9:12, 35; Bo, 10:1.

[2]Quoted in 'Mishluchan Gavoa', Parshas Bo, p.70.

[3]In the same war, a single scud missile in Saudi Arabia succeeded in killing dozens of people.

[4]Kaplan, Impact, p.85.

Rabbi Yehonasan GEFEN - © Torah-Box Account

To access the entire website, sign up for free in less than a minute.

Weekly Parsha


Candle Lighting Candle Lighting - New York

Friday April 19th, 2024 at 19:22 *
Shabbat ends at 20:25 *
change my location
* Times given as an indication, check the times of your community

Upcoming Holiday

Scroll to top