Contact us


The Purim Lesson For Our Children: Yes A Hero Can be Afraid!

Published on Saturday February 27th, 2021

My daughter had a minor surgery a few years ago. To prepare her, my pediatrician recommended the book “Franklin Goes To The Hospital” by Paulette Burgeouis and Brenda Clark.

In the book, Franklin hurts his shell (he is a turtle) playing soccer. He needs to get it fixed and requires a surgical procedure.  During the days leading up to the operation, his friends and family keep telling him how brave he is. When he arrives at the hospital on the day of his surgery, the nurse tells him that they need to take an X-ray. Franklin, a normally mild-mannered turtle, refuses and starts to cry. The nurse asks him what is wrong. He says, (and I paraphrase): “Everyone has been telling me how brave I am. But if you take a picture of my insides you will see that I am very scared. I am not brave at all.”

Now is when the book gets really good. The nurse calmly explains to him: “Franklin, everyone gets scared, especially before surgery. Doing that what you have to do even though you are scared to do it, that is what makes you brave.”

I thought that was the best description of bravery that I ever heard. It gives kids and adults a clear understanding of what bravery is: doing what we need to do despite being scared.

We tend to admire brave people but generally think that they act with courage because they are fearless. We focus on the act of bravery; we rarely think about the conflict and the fear that they may have experienced before they acted courageously. Could it be that they were fearful…and that they overcame those feelings to do something great? If that is the case, doesn’t that make them truly brave? Like it says in Pirkei Avot:  “Who is truly strong? The one who subdues his inclinations.”

I think the Purim story illustrates this idea of courage in a powerful way.  Mordechai sends a message to Esther and tells her to approach the king to save the Jewish people. Esther basically tells him she can’t; she is scared (and rightly so).  She has not been called to the king in 30 days, and anyone who approaches the king without being summoned will be killed.

And then, in one of the most moving speeches in the Megillah, Mordechai tells Esther that she must lay her life on the line in order to save the Jewish people. Esther takes her fear and puts it on the back burner.  She prays to G-d and her fasts. And she goes to see the king. She puts in motion one of the most daring, understated and successful rescue missions in Jewish history. She embodies bravery and courage.

Because of this, she is immortalized as one of the greatest champions of the Jewish people. We read her story year after year as a tribute to the fact that she did not let her fear overwhelm her. She overcame it and acted with courage.

This is an important lesson. Children in this modern age have many fears. Family discord, separation anxiety, or any type of change. Terrorism and other “bad guys.” They also have their little fears – loud noises, the dark, or monsters under the bed.  Teens have fears of not doing well in school, of not getting into college, of not fitting in. They can use stories and role models to help them cope.

So even though my kids are older now, we still reference the Franklin book. I tell my kids, “Remember, being brave and doing brave acts does not mean that you were never scared. It means that you were scared but you did what you had to do anyway, just like our great leader, Esther HaMalka.”

We have so many stories in our Jewish heritage that can support this definition of courage. Avraham Avinu stood up to Nimrod, Yosef HaTzaddik dealt with Pharaoh and settled his father and brothers in a strange land.  Moshe, too, met Pharaoh head-on. Shimon HaTzaddik faced Alexander the Great. Later there were the Court Jews. Earlier this year Bibi Netanyahu had to address the United Nations.

Let’s tell our children: Yes, they were probably scared.  But they overcame their fear and did what they had to do. They knew they needed to in order to keep the Jewish People alive and whole. And if you have to, with G-d’s help, you can do it too.


Have a wonderful Purim!

Adina SOCLOF - © Torah-Box Account

To access the entire website, sign up for free in less than a minute.

Weekly Parsha

Acharei Mot - Kedoshim

Candle Lighting Candle Lighting - New York

Friday April 23th, 2021 at 19:26 *
Shabbat ends at 20:29 *
change my location
* Times given as an indication, check the times of your community

Upcoming Holiday

Scroll to top