Contact us


Miketz: Yosef's Greatness

Published on Thursday January 14th, 2021

The Parsha begins with the account of Yosef’s dramatic elevation from servitude in the Egyptian dungeons to the position of Viceroy over all of Mitzrayim.  

During its account of Yosef’s elevation, the Torah tells us that he had two sons: “And he called the name of the first-born Menashe, for ‘Hashem has caused me to forget (nashani)all my hardship and all my father’s household‘.  And the name of the second he called Ephraim for, ‘Hashem has made me fruitful in the land of my suffering.’[1]”  The simple understanding of the naming of Menashe is that Yosef was thankful to Hashem for enabling him to forget the great suffering he had endured in his fathers’ home. However, this pshat seems very problematic.  It is not difficult to fathom why Yosef was happy to forget the pain he endured at the hands of his brothers, however, it is very hard to understand how he could be glad to forget his grieving father[2].  Accordingly, the Malbim suggests a different way to understand the naming of Menashe. He writes that Yosef was not glad to forget his family, in fact, the very opposite was the case;  he called his first-born Menashe to symbolize that he was worried that he would forget (nashani)all the suffering that he endured at the hands of his family.  The second son was named Ephraim to symbolize that he recognized that Hashem had made him fruitful in the land of his suffering with the emphasis on the fact that even in the time of great success he did not forget the great suffering that he had endured in Mitzrayim.

The Malbim explains in this vein that Yosef made simunim for himself through the names that he gave his sons.  He further writes that this demonstrates Yosef’s great righteousness in that he strived to remember the suffering that he had endured even in the times of good. He continues: “This is also the explanation of why we are commanded to eat Matza together with Maror on Seder night; we should remember the Galusin the time of freedom, because the Galusis the reason for the freedom and the bad brings the good[3].” However, the Malbim does not explain why exactly the ‘bad’ is the reason for the subsequent ‘good’.  Further clarification is required as to why he considers that remembering the bad in the time of good indicates great righteousness.

A solution to these problems can be found in the Sifsei Chaim’s explanation of part of the ‘Al HaNissim’ prayer.  In ‘Al HaNissim’ we thank Hashem for enabling us to defeat the Yavanim:  “You placed the strong in the hands of the weak; and the many in the hands of the few; and the impure in the hands of the pure; and the evil in the hands of the righteous; and the guilty in the hands of those who toil in Your Torah.”  The Sifsei Chaim asks that the first two of these praises do not seem to be parallel with the following three: The implication of the first two is that Hashem enabled the weak to be victorious even though they faced strong enemies; and the few to win even though they were fighting many.  In contrast in the remaining praises the implication is that the pure were successful because their enemies were impure; and that the righteous defeated the Greeks because they were evil.  

He explains that in truth, all the praises are parallel in that they all explain why the Hashmonaim defeated the Yavanim.  When we say that Hashem placed the strong in the hands of the weak and the many in the hands of the few, we mean that He did so because they were weak and few in number they were successful, not despite that fact.  The Sifsei Chaim continues that the Hashmonaim felt their physical weakness and lack of numbers and consequently realized that b’derech hateva they had no chance of overcoming the mighty Yavanim.  Thus they fought with a strong sense of bitachon, recognizing that they could only succeed with great siata dishmaya.  Because they did not rely on their own power, Hashem did indeed help them and caused them to achieve a miraculous victory[4].

With this explanation we can now understand why the Malbim stated that the suffering one endures is the very reason for the subsequent good that he experiences.  When a person finds himself in a situation of difficulty and helplessness it is much easier for him to recognize that he does not have the ability to succeed. As a result of this recognition he turns to HaShem to save him from his desperate situation.  Because of this bitachon, Hashem will likely respond by giving of His unlimited kindness to ensure that the person’s situation drastically improves.  In this way the ’bad times’ that one endures can be the very cause of the subsequent ‘good times’. This feeling of helplessness was the key to the success of the Hashmonaim.

We can also now come to an understanding why the Malbim writes that remembering one’s earlier periods of suffering in times of tranquility is considered a sign of righteousness.  When a person has everything that he needs he is far more prone to feelings of confidence in his own power and ability to succeed. He may no longer see the need to rely on Hashem, rather he will feel self-reliant.  We see this in the second paragraph of Krias Shema: The Torah promises that if we observe the Mitzvos then we will receive abundance. Immediately following this, the Torah warns us about turning away from Hashem - this teaches that the very success that Hashem gives us may be the cause of us turning away from Him. An unfortunate consequence of this attitude of not relying on Hashem may be that Hashem will act measure for measure and desist from giving a person siata dishmaya and as a result he will be at the mercy of derech hateva.

A tzaddik, even in times of abundance, maintains the realization that everything he has is from Hashem and that his only source of success is Hashem’s continuing siata dishmaya.  The greatness of Yosef was that even when he found himself in a position of great power, he never allowed himself to forget his previous situation of total helplessness.  He strived to maintain the recognition that just as then he was in the hands of Hashem, in the same way he was still totally dependent on Hashem’s beneficence for his success.  By feeling the same helplessness in the good times as he felt in the bad, Yosef merited continued siata dishmaya.  It is far easier to feel the need to turn to Hashem in times of difficulty We learn from Yosef that even in time of plenty we must remember the more difficult periods of our life to remind us that even now we are totally reliant upon Hashem in every aspect of our lives.  By maintaining this recognition at all times we are far more likely to merit that Hashem will continue to protect us at all times.

[1]Miketz, 41:51-52.

[2]Rav Shimshon Rafael Hirsch zt”l asks this kasha - see there for his explanation.  The commentaries further ask why Yosef did not reveal himself to Yaakov once he rose to a position of power in Mitzrayim.  One answer offered is that he knew that the brothers had made an oath banning anyone from revealing to Yaakov the events surrounding his sale and he was bound by that oath.

[3]Malbim, 41:51-52.

[4]Sifsei Chaim, Moadim, 2ndChelek, p.136.

Rabbi Yehonasan GEFEN - © Torah-Box Account

To access the entire website, sign up for free in less than a minute.

Weekly Parsha


Candle Lighting Candle Lighting - New York

Friday April 19th, 2024 at 19:22 *
Shabbat ends at 20:25 *
change my location
* Times given as an indication, check the times of your community

Upcoming Holiday

Scroll to top